Girardi | Keese

Ghost Ship Fire Shows Risk-Reward Mentality of the Underground Music Scene

A Q&A with a former nightclub owner


In the aftermath of Oakland's Ghost Ship fire tragedy, many are still looking for answers. We know the warehouse was home to a vibrant underground music scene, a collective that at any given time ranged from resident musicians and artists, who lived there on a semi-permanent basis, to partygoers visiting for the first time on a weekend night.

What outsiders may not realize is that spaces like the Ghost Ship grew out of manufacturing's general decline, which left large vacant mills dotting the urban landscape. Property speculators buy cheap, with visions of rebuilding, redeveloping, and creating vibrant communities not unlike what existed at the Ghost Ship.

But the risk-reward gamble - in which some landlords seem to largely ignore fire code safety and related property concerns - may turn out to be too steep a bet. On condition of anonymity, a former East Coast nightclub owner shed some light on what's at stake.

In the Q&A below, the former nightclub owner brings us back to the Station Night Club fire in Rhode Island, which took place roughly 14 years ago, in 2003.

Does the Ghost Ship remind you of the Station Fire?

In terms of tragedy, yes. In the Station fire, 100 people lost their lives, and more than 200 were injured. I'm sure what happened at the Ghost Ship will stay with the Oakland community like it has in Rhode Island. But there are a lot of other things as well. I see the same type of rallying by local government, in which the government disclaims responsibility. We saw that after the Station fire. I read a report that the Ghost Ship had 10 code complaints. But it's the force of those write-ups that matters in terms of real safety.

What do you mean by the "force" of code complaints?

In Rhode Island, fire marshals have what they call "field notes." Those are different from actual citations. Field notes are just forms letting a property owner know that such-and-such needs to be fixed. Fire marshals might call or swing by months later to check up, as appears to have happened in Oakland, but a citation gives a property owner a limited amount of time to meet the fire code or get shut down. The Ghost Ship hadn't been shut down prior to the fire. As for the Station in Rhode Island, it had several serious code violations, like chained exits, that weren't cited. This contributed to the Station's death toll. I understand the Ghost Ship may have had near to nonexistent emergency lighting, stairway problems, and lack of exits. These are exactly the things that get people killed, given how quickly a fire spreads once started.

What about capacity limits?

There are two things to understand. First, it's a business, even at warehouse shows. Raves and concerts are basically run by young promoters hoping to make a few bucks. Big crowds mean more money. They won't turn anyone away. The second part is that a ton of people packed into a room raises the coolness factor. No one thinks about danger. They're all having a good time. Property owners tend to turn a blind eye. The shows generate money and the rent gets paid. They also put warehouses on the indie scene map as a place to rent space. Underground shows amount to free advertising for landlords.

Given your experience, do you feel there was a way to avoid this tragedy?

At the end of the day, the Ghost Ship fire was a tragedy, and the nature of tragedies is that they are somewhat unpredictable. But with a bit more accountability - like actual citations from the government, as opposed to warnings - you can reduce the likelihood of a tragedy from happening. Either way, the goal should be to make conditions reasonably safe. And, if not, you don't open for business.

Everyone now knows how unsafe conditions were in the Ghost Ship. But this knowledge comes after-the-fact. Unfortunately, nobody did much of anything about these safety concerns prior to the fire, and people died because of it.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

DISCLAIMER: Case results depend upon a variety of factors unique to each case. Case results do not guarantee or predict a similar result. Any testimonials and endorsements at this site do not constitute a guarantee, warranty, or prediction regarding the outcome of your legal matter or potential legal matter.


The Soto Verdict

Girardi | Keese attorneys have won a $2.3M verdict for a Long Beach resident run over by a Parks & Rec truck. Read more here.

The Madero Verdict

Attorney Christopher T. Aumais persuaded a San Bernardino County jury to deliver an  exceptionally high verdict in an area known for low jury awards.

A Champion of Justice

Partner Amy Fisch Solomon was a Champion of Justice in 2015, proving that success in law isn't just about the size of your verdict or settlement.

Own a VW Diesel?

Read about VW's emissions scandal and 
our class action against the automaker.


Learn About Our Referral Network Read More

Our Attorneys

Meet our award-winning team Read More


The true measure of a lawyer isn’t the awards, but what the awards say about the lawyer: dedication and commitment to the client.

Review Us
Super Lawyers Distinguished AV | Lexis Nexis | Martindale-Hubbell | Peer Review Rated For Ethical Standards and Legal Ability American Association For Justice Consumer Attorneys Association Of Los Angeles Consumer Attorneys California Supreme Court Icon 7 Icon Best Lawyers | Best Law Firms 2014 | U.S. News American Board of Trial Advocates Law Dragon America's Top 100 Attorneys | Lifetime Achievement Martindale-Hubbell | AV Preeminent | Peer Review Rated For Highest Level of Professional Excellence | 2017