Girardi | Keese

Energy at Any Cost? The Standing Rock Sioux Say No

From Hinkley to North Dakota: When will the environment start to matter?


When Pacific Gas and Electric Company polluted the groundwater of Hinkley, Calif., in the 1950s and 1960s, people suffered greatly for decades. Cancer and other serious ailments afflicted Hinkley residents. Many were sickened, and some lost their lives, from the cancer-causing agent chromium-6, used as part of PG&E's natural gas pipeline project.

It came to be known colloquially as the Erin Brockovich case (popularized by the movie of the same name), after the consumer activist who rallied for the residents of Hinkley. The case illustrates why it's so important to protect our environment.

And this is not just a "tree-hugging" notion to dismiss out of hand.

When the environment suffers, people suffer, too.

This notion runs through the protests waged now by the Standing Rock Sioux in North Dakota against Energy Transfer Partners, the Dallas-based company working to construct a pipeline through sacred Native American land, including the Missouri River and Cannon Ball River.

Despite the claims of Energy Transfer Partners that the environmental concerns are "unfounded," as Reuters reports, the Standing Rock Sioux - as well as hundreds of other Native American tribes throughout the country - seem just as "committed" to stopping pipeline construction as the company is in completing it.

After all, oil spills and pipeline explosions are a regular part of the news cycle.

Even though the Erin Brockovich case involved a different place, time, and people, it too involved environmental damage caused by the very same industry that appears to pursue profit at seemingly any cost.

The Standing Rock Sioux have won - for now.

The Obama administration has issued an order halting construction on federal land, following a recent court ruling that denied the tribe's request to stop construction. It has also asked Energy Transfer Partners to stop construction on private land.

But the question remains: Is environmental harm, and its potential fallout, like the fallout in Hinkley many years ago, a reasonable cost to pay for shipping crude oil directly from the Bakken shale through a 1,000+ mile pipeline to the Gulf?

The Standing Rock Sioux would say no. So might the people of Hinkley.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information


The Soto Verdict

Girardi | Keese attorneys have won a $2.3M verdict for a Long Beach resident run over by a Parks & Rec truck. Read more here.

The Madero Verdict

Attorney Christopher T. Aumais persuaded a San Bernardino County jury to deliver an  exceptionally high verdict in an area known for low jury awards.

A Champion of Justice

Partner Amy Fisch Solomon was a Champion of Justice in 2015, proving that success in law isn't just about the size of your verdict or settlement.

Own a VW Diesel?

Read about VW's emissions scandal and 
our class action against the automaker.


Learn About Our Referral Network Read More

Our Attorneys

Meet our award-winning team Read More


The true measure of a lawyer isn’t the awards, but what the awards say about the lawyer: dedication and commitment to the client.

Super Lawyers Distinguished AV | Lexis Nexis | Martindale-Hubbell | Peer Review Rated For Ethical Standards and Legal Ability American Association For Justice Consumer Attorneys Association Of Los Angeles Consumer Attorneys California Supreme Court Icon 7 Icon Best Lawyers | Best Law Firms 2014 | U.S. News American Board of Trial Advocates Law Dragon America's Top 100 Attorneys | Lifetime Achievement